User:Trap D

From Rosetta Code

Hi TrapD, it's not clear if you had permission for the use of the Prolog Y combinator code? --Paddy3118 09:43, 11 April 2011 (UTC)

I think that that excerpt would qualify for fair use, at least in the U.S.A. (This site is educational, and non-profit, the quoted material is but a small part of the entire work, and the idea that this quote would devalue the book seems absurd). --Rdm 11:32, 11 April 2011 (UTC)
The site is not non-profit. That'd cost too much to set up and maintain. --Michael Mol 14:01, 11 April 2011 (UTC)
That is ironic, but I still think we should be ok on the legal front. When I look at the reference page, the amount of overlap with the prolog y-combinator is vanishingly small, and this site is not going to be doing any harm to the publishers of that book. Unless I am missing something big, it would be difficult to support an assertion that the publishers of that book can have any rights to something so small and algorithmic in character. --Rdm 14:52, 11 April 2011 (UTC)
If I get a C&D, I'll take it down. I'd prefer a clean-room solution, of course. --Michael Mol 14:55, 11 April 2011 (UTC)

How about we remove the code until we have permission. That way we are covered, and I like that much better than keeping it until someone gets a take-down notice! --Paddy3118 15:54, 11 April 2011 (UTC)

Permission for what, exactly? Seriously, when I look at that prolog code, and I look at the reference (which itself was a compare and contrast page), I am having a hard time seeing what this takedown is about. --Rdm 16:49, 11 April 2011 (UTC)

Hi guys. Trap D - I read your note on my talk page, and I have no objections in you posting the code if you think your code is sufficiently different. I just:

  1. Noted you made reference to the book and thought the code was from the the book rather than based on it.
  2. Looked at the license on one of their code pages and noted that their license didn't look compatable to RC.
  3. I did search for 'combinator' on the books page - which was used in your code, and did not find it. I then ignored that as I thought maybe a variable name had been changed.

If you have trouble copying your code from the older version here then I could do it for you? --Paddy3118 19:54, 11 April 2011 (UTC)